Sharing runs through cigar culture. A smoker with a good box opens it for friends, a host offers cigars after dinner, and smokers who meet trade cigars to try each other's favorites. In the United States, a gathering of smokers who bring cigars to share is called a herf, a word that spread through online cigar groups in the 1990s. The customs of offering are simple, and nearly all of them come from thinking about what the other person would like.
Offering a Cigar
Open the box, the humidor or your cigar case and let your guest choose, rather than choosing for them. If you know the cigars, a word about each helps: which is mild and which is full, which is short and which will take two hours. Restaurants that serve cigars follow the same order, presenting the open box with the cigars facing the guest, who chooses first.
Offer the cigar whole. Leave it uncut, so your guest can cut it the way they like, and leave the band on, so they know what they are smoking. If you hand over a single cigar, hold it by the body, so your fingers stay away from the head that your guest will put in their mouth. Then offer your cutter and a light, and let your guest light up first.
Choose what you offer with the guest in mind. Someone who rarely smokes will enjoy a mild or medium cigar in a modest size far more than the strongest cigar you own: strength is nicotine, and how much of it a person enjoys depends on how used to it they are, as Strength Tolerance Over Time explains in Strength vs. Body. Size matters too, because a large cigar can take two hours, and a guest may not have them. Offer cigars that have been well kept, since a dry or damp cigar is a poor gift to put in anyone's hand.
One thing not to do is cut a cigar in half to share it. The blend tastes different along the length, so the two halves are not the same cigar, and cutting through the middle tends to loosen the wrapper.
Accepting and Declining
If you are offered a cigar, accept it with thanks or decline it simply; a plain "No, thank you" needs no explanation. If your own offer is declined, let it go. Pressing a cigar on someone is bad form, and plenty of people don't smoke, or don't want to on a given day.
If you accept a cigar but don't want to smoke it now, it is perfectly proper to keep it for another time, in the same way that a host who is given a bottle of wine is under no obligation to open it at dinner. Thank the giver, and tell them later what you thought of it. If you do smoke it together, they will enjoy hearing what you notice in it; Talking About Cigars Politely has more on that.
Someone Else's Humidor
Never take a cigar from someone else's humidor or box without being asked, even if it stands open and the owner has left the room. A humidor often holds cigars its owner has aged for years or is keeping for an occasion, and there is no way to tell from the outside which is which. Even when a host says "help yourself", take one, and take it from the box that was opened for you.
Bringing Cigars to Share
When you are invited to smoke at someone's home or to join a gathering, bring cigars of your own, more than you need, and offer some to your host and to the others. At a herf it is common to bring extras to pass around, and to try what others brought. In a cigar lounge, the house rules decide whether you may smoke cigars bought elsewhere at all; Cigar Lounge Etiquette explains them.
