Conversation is half the pleasure of smoking in company, and cigars give people plenty to talk about: where a cigar comes from, how it is made, what it tastes like and how it changes as it burns. Because taste is personal, the same cigar can delight one smoker and disappoint another, and the way people talk about cigars decides whether the conversation stays a pleasure.
Describe, Don't Judge
Talk about what you notice: the aroma before lighting, the flavors, the draw, the burn, and how the cigar changes from the first third to the last. "I'm getting cedar and a little black pepper" opens a conversation, while "this is harsh" closes it. "Too strong for me" describes your experience, while "too strong" passes judgment on someone else's choice. The words for describing a cigar are covered in Flavor & Aroma Descriptors in Cigar Terminology, and in How to Taste and Describe and Building Vocabulary in Tasting Notes.
Palates differ, and the same cigar tastes different after a meal, with a drink or on another day. A creamy Connecticut-wrapped cigar and a full Nicaraguan puro are different things, not a better and a worse one, and the cigar you would never choose may be your neighbor's favorite. Saying so is no insult to anyone.
Strength Is Not a Contest
Some smokers like to boast about the strongest cigars they can handle. Strength, though, is nicotine, and being able to smoke strong cigars says more about tolerance, a physical adaptation, than about taste or knowledge, as Strength vs. Body explains. Never tease someone for preferring mild cigars or for feeling the effects of a strong one. A glass of water and a quiet word help more.
Talking With Newcomers
Cigars come with a vocabulary of their own: ligero, vitola, ring gauge, cold draw, retrohale. With a newcomer, explain a term when you use it, or say the same thing in plain words. Ask what they enjoy before recommending anything, and recommend rather than instruct.
Don't correct the way someone cuts, lights or smokes their cigar unless they ask. Telling others how to smoke is one of the habits experienced smokers find most tiresome in each other. If a newcomer does ask for help, give it simply and kindly, the way someone once helped you.
Subjects That Need Care
Some subjects stir up more feeling than others. The debate over Cuban and non-Cuban cigars is an old one, and fine cigars come from Cuba, Nicaragua, the Dominican Republic, Honduras and elsewhere; "it isn't a real cigar unless it's Cuban" is a prejudice, not knowledge. The Cuban vs. Non-Cuban topic sets out what really differs.
Authenticity is another. Cuban cigars are widely counterfeited, but questioning whether someone's cigar is genuine, especially in front of others, is rude. If they ask your opinion, Certification and Security in Cigar Boxes explains how to check a box. In the United States, where Cuban cigars cannot legally be brought in even for personal use, it is also tactful not to ask anyone where their Cuban cigars came from.
Price and ratings need a light touch too. Remarking on what someone's cigar cost, or using a published score to settle an argument about taste, rarely goes well; a rating is one reviewer's opinion of one cigar on one day.
Listening and Quiet
Ask other smokers what they are smoking and what they like about it, and listen to the answer. Let others speak as much as you do; knowledge is welcome, but a lecture is not. Not every puff needs a comment, either. Smoking together in comfortable silence is part of the pleasure, and many smokers treasure it.
