Tasting notes give smokers a shared language for something personal. This lesson explains how taste, aroma and flavor differ, the common flavor families and the notes often tied to each wrapper, the words for strength, body, texture and finish, how smokers describe a cigar that changes as it burns, and the words for faults. Tasting Notes covers how to taste in practice, and Strength vs. Body explains strength and body in depth.
Taste, aroma and flavor
Taste is what the tongue senses, and it is limited to sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami. Aroma is what the nose senses: the smell of the unlit cigar, of the smoke in the air, and of the smoke in your mouth as it reaches the back of the nose. Flavor is the two together, along with the feel of the smoke in the mouth. Because aroma carries most of what we call flavor, the nose matters more than the tongue.
Smokers use a few more words for the moments when aroma shows. The pre-light aroma is the smell of the unlit cigar, at the foot and along the wrapper. A cold draw is the taste of air drawn through the cut cigar before lighting. A retrohale is letting some smoke out gently through the nose, so that you smell it from inside; it brings out the aroma, and spice most of all. The room note is the smell of the smoke in the room, as other people notice it. Cigar smoke is drawn into the mouth and tasted, not inhaled.
Flavor families
There is no single official list of cigar flavors, but most tasting guides group notes into families like the ones below. Naming the family first, such as wood or spice, and then narrowing it down to a note, such as cedar or black pepper, is easier than reaching straight for the exact note.
| Family | Common notes |
|---|---|
| Wood | Cedar, oak |
| Earth | Soil, forest floor, mushroom, mineral |
| Leather and savory | Leather, roasted meat, umami |
| Spice | Black pepper, red pepper, cinnamon, nutmeg, clove |
| Sweet | Honey, caramel, molasses, brown sugar, vanilla |
| Nuts | Almond, peanut, cashew, hazelnut, walnut |
| Coffee and cocoa | Espresso, coffee bean, cocoa, dark chocolate |
| Bread and cream | Toast, bread, cream, butter |
| Fruit | Raisin, fig, dried fruit, citrus peel, cherry |
| Floral and herbal | Flowers, tea, hay, grass, dried herbs |
The notes come from the leaf itself: from its seed and soil, and from how it was fermented and aged. Cedar can also come from the cedar of the box and the humidor. Makers print tasting notes on boxes and web pages, such as notes of cream, coffee, bread and cocoa, and reviewers write their own. Both are a guide rather than a promise, because palates differ, and the same cigar tastes different after a meal, with a drink or on another day.
Notes tied to wrappers
Reviews often link certain notes to certain wrappers. These are tendencies, not rules: the binder and filler shape a cigar's flavor as much as the wrapper does, and two cigars with the same wrapper can taste very different. The table gives the notes reviewers name most often for the common wrappers.
| Wrapper | Notes often named |
|---|---|
| Connecticut Shade | Cream, cedar, hay and nuts; usually mild |
| Habano and Corojo | Pepper, spice, cedar and earth |
| Cameroon | Gentle, sweet spice and cedar |
| Maduro (Broadleaf, San Andrés, Arapiraca) | Cocoa, coffee, dark chocolate and natural sweetness |
| Candela | Grass and fresh green leaf |
The pattern follows how each wrapper is grown and cured: the pale, shade-grown Connecticut is the creamiest and mildest, the longer, hotter fermentation of maduro brings out sweetness and cocoa, and the green candela, dried quickly to keep its chlorophyll, tastes of green leaf.
Strength and body
Strength is how strong the nicotine effect feels (fortaleza, in Spanish), and it comes mainly from the blend, above all from the ligero. Body is how full and rich the smoke feels in the mouth, from light to full. The two often go together but don't have to: a cigar can be full of flavor yet mild in strength, and a peppery cigar isn't necessarily a strong one.
Habanos ranks its lines by flavor in five steps, from light to full, and notes that taste still varies between the sizes of a line. Most makers and shops elsewhere label strength or body mild, medium or full, often with steps in between, such as medium to full. Strength vs. Body explains how to judge each.
Texture and finish
Mouthfeel is how the smoke feels in the mouth: creamy, smooth, dry, oily, thin or chewy. Creamy smoke is soft and rounded, a word often used of mild cigars, while astringent smoke has a drying, puckering feel. Smoke volume is how much smoke each puff gives, from thin to thick. The finish, also called the aftertaste, is what stays in the mouth after the smoke is gone: short or long, clean or bitter.
How a cigar changes as it burns
Reviewers describe a cigar in thirds, the first, second and final third, because its flavor and strength change as it burns, and many cigars grow fuller toward the end. A transition is a clear change in flavor from one stage to the next. A linear cigar keeps much the same flavor from start to finish, while a complex one shows many flavors, at once or one after another. Balance means that no single flavor or sensation overwhelms the rest.
Words for faults
Most off flavors point to how a cigar is being smoked or how it was made or stored, which is why the words are worth knowing. The table pairs each word with what it usually points to.
| Word | What it usually points to |
|---|---|
| Hot, harsh | Puffing too fast |
| Bitter, acrid | An overheated coal, or stale smoke left in the cigar |
| Tongue bite | A sting on the tip of the tongue, from smoke that is too hot |
| Charred, burnt | A flame held too long or too close when lighting or relighting |
| Ammonia | Leaf that wasn't fermented or rested long enough, usually in a very young cigar |
| Flat | A cigar that has dried out |
| Musty | A cigar stored too humid, or near mold |
| Tarry, heavy | Oils and tars building up toward the head near the end |
Hot, harsh smoke, bitterness and tongue bite all come from heat, and the cure is the same: slow down to about one gentle puff a minute, and purge a cigar that has turned bitter. A charred taste comes from the lighting itself, so a gentler, more patient toast avoids it. Ammonia, flatness and mustiness come from the leaf or from storage, and smoking more slowly won't fix them. A tarry taste is simply the end of the cigar, and many smokers put it down with an inch or two left.
Building a vocabulary
Naming flavors gets easier with practice, and a few habits help. A difference is easier to name than a single flavor, so smoking two cigars side by side teaches faster than smoking one. Naming the family first and then the note narrows the search. Scoring the same six points the Cuban catadores use, draw, burn, aroma, flavor, strength and overall quality, keeps a tasting from drifting into flavor alone. And after a long smoke or several cigars, flavors grow dull; water, something plain to eat or a break brings the palate back.
