Smoking in New York bars and restaurants has been illegal since 2003, so the city's cigar smokers gather instead in a few shops that are licensed to let them light up. The Cigar Inn is one of the best known. This lesson follows it from a 400-square-foot shop to a pair of Manhattan institutions and through the 2015 sale that ended the magazine's branding on it.
The Fakih brothers
The Cigar Inn began as a small shop, about 400 square feet, on the Upper East Side, run by the brothers Gus, Billy and Bass Fakih. Gus Fakih had spent more than twenty years in the cigar business by the time they sold. The brothers' aim was more than a shop: a room where their customers could smoke, in a city that had all but outlawed doing so anywhere else, and the shop's own accounts call it home to the first and only branded lounge and humidor run by a cigar magazine in the world.
The two shops
The Cigar Inn grew to two Manhattan locations, one on the Upper East Side on 73rd Street and the other on Second Avenue in Midtown. The Second Avenue shop opened with a large walk-in humidor, a humidor big enough to step into, and in December 2008 it became the home of a branded lounge and humidor run by a cigar magazine, carrying the magazine's name. The shops' reputation rests on that humidor and on the ease of the room around it: leather chairs, a television for sports, and a steadiness that regulars describe as a small town for gentlemen.
Bring your own bottle
New York's smoking laws shaped the Inn in a second way. Because the laws that allow smoking also bar the serving of much hard liquor in the same room, the shops became bring-your-own-bottle, or BYOB: customers buy their cigars at the counter and bring the drink they want, with liquor stores near at hand. What began as a workaround became part of the place's character, a club-like ease built on customers who know the routine.
The 2015 sale
In June 2015 the brothers sold the two Cigar Inns to East Side Cigar Co., a firm created for the purchase by Britain's Imperial Tobacco, one of the world's largest tobacco companies, which then also owned the U.S. cigar maker Altadis U.S.A. and half of Habanos S.A. The sale ended the magazine's branding: the magazine's publisher, Marvin R. Shanken, said the magazine could not keep its lounge in a store whose owners also owned a cigar company. The brothers, who said they had been "very particular" about whom they sold to, moved on to their other business ventures, and the shops carried on under the new owner.
