Cigarero

How to Taste and Describe

Tasting a cigar is a deliberate act, not a guess. It begins before the cigar is lit, with the eye and then the nose, moves to the cold draw and the first puffs, and then, through a slow smoke, follows the flavor from the first third to the last. Retrohaling, letting a little smoke out through the nose, opens the aromas the mouth alone misses, and describing a cigar well means separating what the tongue detects from what the nose does. Slowing down is the whole skill.

Anyone can smoke a cigar, but tasting one is a practice. The difference is attention and pace: a taster works slowly, isolates one sensation at a time and notes when each appears, instead of naming notes at random. The point is not to impress anyone with exotic words but to build a description another smoker can follow, one that says what was there, when it was there and how it changed. This lesson takes a cigar from the box to the last puff in order. Flavor Families gives the broad groups to look for, and Building Vocabulary the words for them.

Before you light

The first reading is with the eye and the nose, before any heat changes the leaf. Look at the wrapper for an even color, fine veins, tight seams and a sheen of oil, and press the cigar gently along its length to check it is firm and springy; this is construction, not flavor, but a badly made cigar never delivers the blend the blender intended, as Construction Defects explains. Then smell the wrapper, and the foot separately. The wrapper, the leaf that touches your lips, usually shows the lighter notes, cedar, hay, cocoa or a little sweetness, while the foot, where the filler is exposed, smells of the deeper blend, earth, spice or the fermenting barn. The two lists are meant to differ, and reading both gives you a first idea of the cigar's shape before a single puff.

Cut the head, then take a cold draw, a gentle pull through the unlit cigar. It tests the draw and leaves a first thin taste on the tongue, often hay, wood, or a little spice. Nothing here is the final cigar, but the wrapper, the foot and the cold draw together set the direction.

Lighting and the first puffs

Light the cigar slowly, heating the whole foot before you draw on it, so the entire face catches at once; the Foot lesson shows the steps. The first three to five puffs carry the taste of lighting itself, a little sulfur from the flame and a sharpness from the char, so tasters wait for them to pass before judging anything. Once the burn has settled, name the family that leads before you name any single note, then the notes within it. Finding the family first keeps the taste from becoming a search for words.

Each cigar is judged in thirds, the first, second and final, as Flavor Development explains, and a good taste note records all three rather than one average impression, because a cigar's family changes as it burns.

Taste and aroma are two senses

The mouth and the nose do different work, and keeping them apart is the core of accurate description. The tongue detects only a few basic tastes: sweet, sour, salty, bitter and savory, the last often called umami. Everything else people call flavor, the cedar, cocoa, leather and pepper, is really aroma, read by the nose while the smoke is in the mouth. Even the sweet and bitter of a cigar arrive partly by smell. A taster therefore separates the two explicitly: structure, the balance of sweet and bitter on the tongue, from aroma, the named notes on the nose.

The retrohale

Because so much of a cigar lives in the nose, the retrohale is the single most useful move a taster learns. It means pushing a little of the smoke out through the nose instead of the mouth, so that the aromatic compounds pass over the olfactory receptors at the top of the nose and are read directly. A small share of each puff is enough; the point is exposure, not a lungful, and beginners should use very little at first, since the spice can sting until the nose grows used to it. Floral notes, baking spices and dried fruit often come only this way, which is why so many recorded notes appear only once a cigar is retrohaled. The retrohale does not add anything that is not there; it just lets the nose reach what the tongue cannot.

Separating what you perceive

A full description separates four things that are easy to blur. Strength is the nicotine effect, felt in the body; body is the weight and fullness of the smoke, felt in the mouth; flavor is what the smoke tastes and smells of; and the finish is what stays after the puff. The Strength vs. Body topic works through the first two, and the lesson is worth keeping at hand, because judging a peppery cigar as "strong" is the commonest mistake in tasting: pepper is a flavor, and a peppery cigar can be mild in nicotine, as Reading Strength and Body explains.

The order of a good note follows the same four, from the general to the specific: body first, then the flavor families, then the specific notes, then the finish, short, medium or long, and clean, bitter or sweet.

Pace, environment and memory

Perception is not a fixed instrument. What you have eaten or drunk, how fast you smoke, how the cigar was kept and even the time of day all shift what you notice, so a taster tries to keep conditions steady and takes what the mouth reports with a grain of salt. Smoking too fast overheats the cigar and turns fragile aromas harsh, while smoking one puff a minute or so keeps the flavor clean, as How Strength Builds During the Smoke describes. Above all, a taster builds a memory. The more you set out to smell ordinary things, spices, woods, coffees, chocolate, leather, and name them, the faster the same notes surface in a cigar. A description is only as good as the memory behind it, and both grow with use.

Log in to save this lesson as read and build your topic progress.

Log in
Lesson 3 of 4 · 10 min readBuilding VocabularyA shared vocabulary turns a private impression into a description another smoker can follow. Professional tasters use five kinds of words: structure, which covers strength and body; flavor and aroma, the named notes; texture, how the smoke feels; and evolution, how the cigar changes. The goal is clarity, not sophistication, and every useful word names something another smoker has smelled or felt. A note written this way can be read back months later and compared.Next lesson