Ash is what remains of the tobacco once it burns. Watching it, along with the burn line and the glowing coal beneath it, tells you a good deal about how a cigar was made and how it is burning, though less about how it tastes than many smokers believe.
What ash is
Burning removes the organic part of the leaf, its cellulose, sugars, oils and the rest. What remains is the mineral part, mainly compounds of potassium and calcium, with smaller amounts of magnesium, manganese, silicon, phosphorus and other elements, all taken up by the plant from the soil. Those minerals stay where they were in the leaves, which is why a good ash keeps the outline of the cigar until it falls.
Color
Ash color depends mostly on the soil and on how completely the tobacco burns. Potassium matters most. Tobacco grown on potassium-rich soil burns well and gives a light gray to white ash, and potassium also makes the leaf more elastic. Chlorine works the other way: leaf high in chlorine burns poorly, which is why tobacco growers keep chlorine low in their soil and fertilizers. Calcium helps form a firm ash, though too much of it slows the burn.
Three kinds of ash are common. A light gray to white ash is typical of tobacco from potassium-rich soils that burns completely. A mottled gray and black ash, often called salt-and-pepper, is common and harmless, and usually reflects the different leaves in the blend and where they grew. A dark gray or black ash shows that the tobacco is not burning completely, because it is too moist, was not fully fermented or lacks the minerals that help it burn.
A white ash is a sign of good combustion, not of good flavor. Plenty of excellent cigars burn with a darker or mottled ash, and the color says nothing about how the smoke tastes.
Firmness and length
How well ash holds together depends mostly on construction. A densely and evenly bunched cigar gives a firm, compact ash that can hold for an inch (2.5 cm) or more; a loosely or unevenly rolled one gives a flaky ash that falls early. Long filler helps, because whole leaves running the length of the cigar keep the ash knitted together, and short-filler cigars rarely hold a long ash. Ligero, the thickest leaf, adds structure too.
Ash length shows good construction, but it is not a contest. Many smokers, and some makers, hold that a longer ash makes the cigar burn cooler, because it limits the air reaching the coal. The effect is widely reported but has never been carefully measured.
The burn line and the coal
Just behind the ash are two signs of how a cigar is burning at that moment. The burn line is the edge where the unburned wrapper meets the ash. On a well-made, well-lit cigar it runs evenly around the whole cigar, and a slightly wavy line is normal. If one side starts to race ahead, a touch-up, a gentle flame held to the lagging side, corrects it before it turns into canoeing or a runner.
The coal, also called the cherry, is the glowing tip under the ash. When the ash comes away, the coal usually stands in a slight cone, because the dense center of the bunch burns a little slower than the outside. A slight cone is normal; a center that has burned hollow is tunneling. If part of the coal turns dark while the rest glows, that part has gone out and needs a touch-up.
Smoking pace
Pace shapes both the coal and the ash. A cigar should be smoked slowly, sipped rather than gulped, and most guides suggest about one gentle puff a minute. Puff much faster and the coal overheats, the smoke turns harsh and bitter, and the ash weakens; puff much slower and the cigar goes out. Cigar smoke is drawn into the mouth and tasted, not inhaled.
Tapping, relighting and finishing
There is no need to tap a cigar's ash the way a cigarette smoker does. Habanos advises letting the ash fall in its own time, preferably into an ashtray, and not worrying about its length. When the ash grows long or starts to crack, it can be rolled off gently against the edge of the ashtray rather than flicked.
A cigar that goes out can be relit: clean off the loose ash, toast the foot again and draw gently. Habanos notes that a Habano can be smoked with enjoyment for at least three quarters of its length. When you have finished, lay the cigar in the ashtray and let it go out on its own rather than crushing it. The Cigar Etiquette topic covers the manners of all three in Ashtray Use and When to Put a Cigar Down, Relighting Etiquette and Letting a Cigar Go Out.
What ash does not tell you
Three beliefs about ash are common and wrong. A white ash does not mean a better cigar, because its color mostly reflects the soil and how completely the tobacco burns. A long ash does not guarantee a good smoke: it shows good construction, and a well-built cigar can still be a dull one. And tapping the ash often does nothing for the burn; it only disturbs the coal.
