The difference between a Cuban cigar and a non-Cuban cigar is not only a matter of leaf and flavor; for several of the best-known names it is a matter of law. This lesson explains the three legal facts that separate the two: the American embargo that keeps Cuban cigars out of the United States, the controlled distribution Habanos S.A. uses everywhere else, and the split that left the same brand names in two owners' hands. Cigar History covers the embargo's origins and the migration of the makers, and Habanos S.A. covers the trading company itself; this lesson states what the two halves of the market may and may not do.
The American embargo
The United States broke its trade with Cuba not long after Fidel Castro's government took power in January 1959. Castro's government nationalized American-owned property and, on September 15, 1960, seized the cigar factories themselves, sixteen of them in a single day. The United States answered with a partial ban in 1960, broke off diplomatic relations in February 1961, and then, in 1962, President John F. Kennedy made the ban total: the year the embargo is usually dated to is 1962, when it was extended to all Cuban trade except food and medicine. The Cuban Assets Control Regulations of 1963 wrote the ban into rule, and later laws, the Cuban Democracy Act of 1992 and the Helms-Burton Act of 1996, tightened it.
The ban is enforced by the Office of Foreign Assets Control, or OFAC, a part of the United States Treasury. What it forbids is wide: a United States person, meaning a citizen or resident or a company under American law, may not import Cuban cigars into the United States or trade in them anywhere; since 2016 a general licence has let such a person buy and smoke them abroad, but bringing them home has been barred again since September 2020. An American traveller in Spain or Canada may therefore smoke a Cuban cigar there, but may not bring it home or sell it. The rules have been loosened and put back several times, but the effect has stayed the same: Cuban cigars are not sold legally anywhere in the United States, and the rest of the world's demand is served while America's is not.
How Habanos distributes
Outside the United States, every Cuban cigar is sold through one route. The company that runs it, Habanos S.A., was formed by the Cuban state in 1994 to take over the export work of Cubatabaco, the state tobacco enterprise created in 1962. In 2000 Altadis, the group formed by the merger of Spain's old tobacco company Tabacalera with France's Seita, bought half of it; that half passed to Imperial Brands in 2008 and in 2020 to Allied Cigar Corporation, whose Madrid company trades as Tabacalera, but the single-channel system has not changed. Habanos S.A. holds the trademarks of every Cuban cigar brand and appoints one distributor in each country to import and sell them, so the same authorized company handles every box of a brand in a given market. Anti-counterfeiting is part of the point of that single channel, as Packaging and Presentation explains, and the United States is the one market it cannot serve. The company also franchises its own shops, La Casa del Habano, and Cigar Terminology describes the importer system and those shops.
The trademark split
The 1960 seizure broke the old brands in two. When Cuba nationalized the factories, the families who had owned them left, and some took their brands abroad; at the same time, because Cuban cigars could not be sold in the United States, American companies registered several of the old Havana names for themselves there. The result is that a number of famous names are made twice, by different owners, as different cigars that share only the name.
The table sets out the six the trade names most often.
| Name | The Cuban cigar | The cigar sold in the United States |
|---|---|---|
| Cohiba | Made in Cuba for Habanos S.A., from Vuelta Abajo leaf | General Cigar Co. registered the name in 1978; made in the Dominican Republic, without Cuban tobacco, the "red dot" Cohiba |
| Montecristo | Made in Cuba for Habanos S.A. | Made in the Dominican Republic, by Altadis USA |
| Romeo y Julieta | Made in Cuba for Habanos S.A. | Made in the Dominican Republic, by Altadis USA |
| H. Upmann | Made in Cuba for Habanos S.A. | Made by Altadis USA |
| Partagás | Made in Cuba for Habanos S.A. | Made by General Cigar Co., which has made its Partagás since 1978 |
| Trinidad | Made in Cuba for Habanos S.A., at El Laguito from 1969 | Made by Altadis USA |
Two American companies own the non-Cuban versions. General Cigar Co., today part of Scandinavian Tobacco Group, holds Cohiba and Partagás alongside Punch and Hoyo de Monterrey, which it took on in 1997. Altadis USA, once the American arm of the Spanish-French Altadis, holds the Dominican-made versions of Montecristo, Romeo y Julieta, H. Upmann and Trinidad. Montecristo and H. Upmann came from the American firm Consolidated Cigar, and Romeo y Julieta from Hollco Rohr, the importer that the Spanish monopoly Tabacalera bought in 1997, two years before it merged with France's SEITA to form Altadis. The two sides have fought over the names in American courts, in particular over Cohiba, which Cubatabaco has sought to win back. What matters to a smoker is simpler: the two cigars under one name are unrelated products, one Cuban and one not, and a shop's Cohiba in the United States is the General Cigar one, because the Cuban Cohiba cannot be sold there at all. Cigar Terminology states the same point, and Major Cigar Brands tells the two sides' stories.
Two markets, one name
These three facts make the market itself split. The United States, the largest cigar market, buys only non-Cuban cigars and the non-Cuban versions of the old names; the rest of the world can buy both, through Habanos S.A.'s distributors on one side and through free trade in the Dominican Republic, Nicaragua and Honduras on the other. A name such as Montecristo is therefore a Cuban cigar in London and a different, Dominican-made cigar in New York, legally and by design, not by accident.
