Cigarero

Guillotine, Punch, V-Cut

A hand-rolled cigar is closed at the head by its cap and has to be opened before it will draw. There are three common cuts: the straight cut, made with a guillotine or cigar scissors, which takes the end off the head; the punch, which bores a round hole in the cap; and the V-cut, which notches a wedge across it. All three aim at the same result, an opening wide enough for an easy draw that leaves enough of the cap to hold the wrapper in place.

Every hand-rolled cigar is sealed at the head by the cap, a small piece of wrapper leaf that locks the wrapper in place, and until that end is opened no smoke can pass. The foot, the end you light, is already open. How the head is opened decides how freely the cigar draws and whether the wrapper holds together for the hour that follows, which makes the cut the first thing in a smoke that can go right or wrong. The tool is a cigar cutter, cortapuros in Spanish, and three cuts cover nearly every cigar made today, in Cuba as in Nicaragua, the Dominican Republic and Honduras: the straight cut, the punch and the V-cut. The Cigar Anatomy lesson Cap (Perilla) explains how the cap is made and the styles of head you will meet.

Where to Cut

Whatever the tool, the cut belongs just above the line where the cap meets the wrapper. On a round head that line usually sits about 2 mm from the end. Where the seam is hard to see, cut a little above the shoulder, the curve where the head meets the body. The cut has to leave part of the cap in place, because the cap is all that holds the wrapper at the head: cut below it and the wrapper can loosen and start to unravel as the cigar warms in your mouth. Taking too little is always the safer mistake. A cut that proves too small can be deepened by a millimeter, but a cap cut away cannot be put back.

Pointed heads need a different approach. Torpedoes, pyramids and belicosos, from the Cuban Montecristo No. 2 to the many figurados made in Nicaragua and the Dominican Republic, narrow to a point, and Habanos suggests cutting them about 3 mm from the tip. Because the head widens toward the body, every extra millimeter opens the draw further, so it pays to start small and take a little more only if the draw is still tight. Perfectos, such as Arturo Fuente's Hemingway cigars from the Dominican Republic, are pointed at both ends, and their head is cut the same way.

A few heads need a step of their own. A pigtail, the curl of twisted wrapper that is the signature of the Cuban brand Trinidad, is snipped off first, and so is the trimmed end of a flag head; the head is then cut as usual. The chisel, a head pressed flat into a wedge and the signature of La Flor Dominicana in the Dominican Republic, has no round cap to work on and is opened with a straight cut across its edge.

The Straight Cut

The straight cut takes the end off the head in a single flat plane and leaves the widest opening of the three, so it gives the most open draw. It works on every shape, round or pointed, which makes it the most widely used cut. It is made with a guillotine or with cigar scissors.

A guillotine is a small frame with a hole for the cigar and one or two blades that slide across it. A single blade cuts from one side, pressing the head against the frame as it passes, and if the blade is dull or the stroke slow, it can pinch the head out of round. A double-blade guillotine closes from both sides at once and meets in the middle, so it holds the cigar steady and pinches less. Either way, the cut should be one quick, firm stroke. Squeezing slowly crushes the head before the blade gets through, and a dull blade tears the cap instead of slicing it. Guillotines are made for a stated maximum ring gauge, the diameter of a cigar in 64ths of an inch, and the thickest cigars, of 60 ring gauge and more, which sell best in the United States and Asia, need a cutter wide enough to take them.

Cigar scissors, with short curved blades shaped to hold the head, make the same straight cut. They can cut very cleanly, but they ask for a steadier hand than a guillotine, and a pair that does not balance well in the hand is hard to use precisely.

The Punch

A punch is a small round blade that bores a hole in the center of the cap instead of taking the end off. The rest of the cap stays in place, so the head keeps its shape and the wrapper is held firmly. Less of the filler is exposed, and fewer loose flakes of tobacco reach the mouth. The draw through a punched hole is tighter than through a straight cut, and the smoke comes in a narrower stream.

A punch needs a broad, rounded cap to work on. It cannot open a pointed head or a chisel, and on a very slim cigar its hole takes almost the whole cap. Its critics point out that a small hole can clog with moisture and tobacco late in the smoke. Punch Sizes and Mechanisms explains how to choose a punch and use it well.

The V-Cut

The V-cut, also called the wedge or cat's eye cut, notches a V-shaped groove across the head with a cutter whose blade is shaped like the letter. It opens more of the head than a punch while leaving more of the cap than a straight cut. The draw is usually easy, sometimes so easy that the smoke runs hot, and the wedge is fragile: clench or chew the head and it can close up. A V-cut needs a sharp, well-made cutter, since a cheap one cuts too deep and can make the cigar burn unevenly, and it works best on round heads thick enough to take the notch. Habanos advises against V-cutters for its cigars, because, it says, they tend to tear the cap.

Comparing the Cuts

The three cuts differ in how much of the head they open and which heads they suit, as the table shows.

CutMade withHow it opens the headDrawSuits
Straight cutGuillotine or cigar scissorsTakes the end off, just above the cap lineThe most openEvery shape, round or pointed
PunchPunch cutterBores a round hole in the center of the capTighter, in a narrow streamRound heads with a broad cap
V-cutV-cutterNotches a wedge across the headEasy, and can run hotRound heads of medium to thick ring gauge

Only the straight cut works on every head, so a guillotine or a pair of cigar scissors is the one tool that will open any cigar. The punch and the V-cut are choices for round heads, made for the kind of draw you prefer.

How Not to Cut

Some ways of opening a cigar do more harm than good. Piercing the head with a match or a cocktail stick compresses the filler and blocks the draw instead of opening it. A deep piercing with a pointed lance can bore a narrow channel through the center of the bunch, which then burns hot, while tar collects at the head. Biting the end off is no better: teeth tear instead of cutting, you cannot see where you are biting, and you end up with wet tobacco in your mouth. A very sharp knife can cut a cigar in an emergency, but only with a single, steady stroke. Whatever the blade, keep it clean and dry, and never clean it with oil, which leaves a residue that the next cigar picks up.

A draw tool, a thin pick pushed through the head, is not a cutter. Its job is to clear a plug near the cap after a cigar has been cut, as Cigar Terminology explains, and How to Cut and Light Without Charring shows when to use it.

Log in to save this lesson as read and build your topic progress.

Log in
Lesson 2 of 5 · 11 min readMatches vs Torch vs Soft FlameA cigar can be lit with a wooden match, a cedar spill, a soft-flame lighter or a torch lighter. What matters is that the flame has no smell of its own and that its heat reaches the whole foot evenly. Matches and cedar spills are the traditional choices and the gentlest; a soft flame is quiet and easy to control indoors; a torch is hot and fast and stands up to wind, but scorches easily. Petrol lighters, wax matches and candles leave their smell in the tobacco.Next lesson