The punch, introduced in Guillotine, Punch, V-Cut, opens a cigar by removing a small disc from the center of the cap. Because the rest of the cap stays where the roller put it, the head keeps its shape and the wrapper stays locked in place, and the opening can be made larger or smaller simply by choosing a different blade. That choice, and the way the punch is used, decide how well a punched cigar draws.
Sizes
Punch blades are measured by the diameter of the hole they cut, and most fall between about 6 and 14 mm. Three-blade punches offer sets such as 7, 9 and 12 mm or 6, 10 and 14 mm, enough between them to open cigars of 60 ring gauge and more.
The right size depends on the width of the head. Ring gauge measures a cigar's diameter in 64ths of an inch, so a 50-ring robusto is about 20 mm across, a 60-ring gordo about 24 mm and a 38-ring lancero about 15 mm. A 9 mm hole opens less than half the width of a robusto's head, but on a lancero the same hole takes about 60 percent of it and leaves little cap around it. The aim is a hole large enough for an easy draw that still leaves a firm rim of cap all round. On a slim cigar that means a small blade, or a straight cut instead. On a thick one it means a larger blade, since a small hole in a wide head gives a tight draw that tempts you to puff hard.
Using a Punch
Press the punch straight into the center of the cap, square to the head, turn it a little so the blade cuts cleanly through the leaf, and draw it out. The small disc of tobacco it cuts, the plug, comes out with it. Take only the cap: a punch does its work in the first few millimeters, and pushing it deep into the filler only loosens tobacco that can later fall into your mouth or block the hole. An off-center hole weakens one side of the cap, and a blunt blade tears the leaf around the hole instead of cutting it. Then take a cold draw, as after any cut.
Kinds of Punch
The mechanism is a matter of convenience and safety, since the cut itself is the same. The table compares the common kinds.
| Kind | How it works | Advantages | Drawbacks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bullet punch | A small steel cylinder, often on a key ring, whose cap twists off to bare the blade | Small and simple | The cap is easy to lose, which leaves the blade exposed |
| Spring-loaded punch | A button pushes the blade out of the body; a plunger then pushes the plug out | The blade stays covered between cuts, and the plug is ejected | More moving parts to wear |
| Multi-blade punch | Two or three blades of different sizes in one body | One tool for slim and thick cigars | Bulkier |
| Punch built into a lighter | A small blade set into the base or side of a lighter | One less thing to carry | Often one size only |
For a smoker who keeps to one size of cigar, a single punch of the right size is enough. One who smokes everything from a corona to a gordo is better served by a multi-blade punch, or by a guillotine for the cigars a punch cannot open.
When Not to Punch
A punch needs a broad, rounded cap. It cannot open a pointed head, such as a torpedo, pyramid, belicoso or perfecto, nor a chisel, and it suits a slim cigar such as a lancero only with its smallest blade. A flat or very thin cap can crack around the hole, and a cigar that has dried out may split. In all of these cases a straight cut is the better choice.
Late in the Smoke
Because every puff passes through one small opening, moisture and tar can collect around a punched hole as the cigar burns down, and a cigar that tasted clean can turn bitter or tarry in its last third. A straight cut across the head, just deep enough to take off the punched end, then gives a fresh, wider opening. Some tarriness near the end is normal for any cigar, however it was cut, and many smokers put a cigar down with an inch or two left.
Looking After a Punch
A punch blade is small, and it dulls with use. Wipe tobacco and residue off it after smoking, keep it dry, and never clean it with oil, which leaves a taste on the next cigar. When it starts to tear the leaf rather than cut it, replace it or have it sharpened.
