Cigarero

Cigar Aficionado

Cigar Aficionado is the American magazine that Marvin R. Shanken launched in New York in the fall of 1992, and it became the most influential publication the premium cigar trade has had. It arrived just as American demand for handmade cigars began to climb, and it is widely credited with helping to set off the boom of the 1990s. It mixes blind-tasted cigar ratings with celebrity interviews and the wider good life, and its annual Cigar of the Year still moves sales from Havana to Estelí.

Most magazines report on a trade. Cigar Aficionado helped to change one. When it first appeared, the American market for premium handmade cigars had been flat for a decade at about 100 million cigars a year; within five years it had passed 400 million. The magazine was not the only cause, but it gave the new demand a voice, a look and a way to judge cigars. This lesson tells how the magazine began, how its ratings work, what it did during the boom, and how it has been criticized. Marvin R. Shanken's life is told in Cigar Personalities, and Cigar Boom (90s) tells the boom itself.

A wine publisher's idea

Shanken came to cigars from wine. In 1979 he bought a small wine newspaper with a circulation of about 5,000 and built it into one of the world's best-known wine magazines, which adopted the 100-point rating scale for wine in 1985. A smoker himself, he had written a column in that magazine in 1984 called "I Love A Good Smoke". In 1991 he travelled to Cuba for a cover story on Cuban cigars, and on the way home he decided to start a magazine for cigar smokers. He first thought of a newsletter. His staff and fellow business owners to whom he showed a mock-up advised against the whole idea, since cigar smoking was then widely seen as an old man's habit in decline. He went ahead anyway. The working title was "The Humidor"; the name the magazine took was drawn from the old column.

The first issue

The first issue reached newsstands in the fall of 1992; a 1993 newspaper report dates the launch to September. It was one of 443 new American magazines that year and the only one devoted to cigars. Shanken printed 100,000 copies, many of them sent free to likely readers, and by his account the magazine made a profit from its first issue. From the start it was more than a buyer's guide. Cigars filled only part of each issue, and the rest went to the things a prosperous smoker might also enjoy: wine and spirits, travel, cars, watches, sport and the people who made news. That formula aimed at two audiences at once, wealthy readers and the advertisers who wanted to reach them, and it is still the magazine's shape.

Covers and the Castro interview

Celebrity covers became the magazine's signature. Its first living celebrity on the cover, the radio host Rush Limbaugh, appeared in the spring of 1994, and later covers carried film stars, athletes and businesspeople, among them Jack Nicholson, Arnold Schwarzenegger and Michael Jordan, whose November 2017 cover marked the magazine's 25th anniversary. The most famous early issue was political. On February 3, 1994, after two years of requests, Shanken interviewed Fidel Castro in Havana, and the interview ran as the cover story of the summer 1994 issue. Castro gave very few interviews to foreign journalists, and a cigar magazine securing one made news far outside the cigar world. The same year Shanken staged the Paris evening told in Dinner of the Century, where the Trinidad, until then a Cuban diplomatic gift, was smoked by paying guests for the first time.

The magazine and the boom

The magazine's launch coincided with the turn in the American market. Imports of premium cigars rose about 4 percent in the last quarter of 1992 and then much faster each year, until by 1997 they had more than quadrupled. The magazine made cigars look like a reward for success, put them on the covers of a newsstand that had ignored them, and taught a new audience the vocabulary of wrapper, filler, ring gauge and vintage. Industry figures credited it with starting the boom, and a 1998 monograph on cigars from the U.S. National Cancer Institute likewise linked the magazine to the resurgence of cigar smoking. A cause and a coincidence are hard to separate here: a strong economy, a generation of newly rich professionals and cigar smoking in films all pushed the same way. What is clear is that the magazine both reported the boom and fed it. The demand it helped create ran ahead of the tobacco that existed to meet it, which is why the boom ended in an oversupply of poorly made cigars in 1997. Cigar Boom (90s) gives the numbers.

How the ratings work

The magazine's ratings are its commercial weight. Every cigar is tasted blind, as it has been since 1992: a coordinator removes the band and replaces it with a plain numbered label, so the tasting panel does not know the brand or the price. Each cigar is scored on a 100-point scale, the system the publisher's wine magazine had made familiar, and the score summarizes appearance and construction, smoking performance, flavor and overall impression. The magazine calls a cigar that scores 95 or more a classic, and scores of 90 and above mark the cigars it recommends most strongly. The labels for the lower ranges are quoted differently from source to source, so this lesson leaves them out.

In practice scores bunch near the top. In 2021, for example, the magazine rated 628 handmade cigars across its six issues and the 24 issues of Cigar Insider, its twice-monthly newsletter; 268 of them, about 43 percent, scored 90 or more, and only four reached 95. A score in the 90s is therefore common enough to be expected of a good cigar, and the difference between 91 and 94 is what makers fight over. A high score is printed on shop shelves and in advertisements, and it can empty a factory's stock within weeks, which is why makers and retailers watch the ratings so closely.

Cigar of the Year

Since 2004 the magazine has ended each year with a Top 25. The panel retastes, blind, cigars that scored highly during the year, and ranks the best of them; the cigar at the top is named Cigar of the Year. The winners, listed below with their scores and the country where each was made, are a fair map of where fine cigars come from in the twenty-first century.

YearCigarScoreMade in
2004Padrón Serie 1926 40th Anniversary93Nicaragua
2005Fuente Fuente OpusX Double Corona95Dominican Republic
2006Bolívar Royal Corona94Cuba
2007Padrón Serie 1926 No. 997Nicaragua
2008Casa Magna Colorado Robusto93Nicaragua
2009Padrón Family Reserve No. 45 Maduro95Nicaragua
2010Cohiba Behike BHK 5297Cuba
2011Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill96Honduras
2012Flor de las Antillas Toro96Nicaragua
2013Montecristo No. 296Cuba
2014Oliva Serie V Melanio Figurado96Nicaragua
2015My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Box Pressed97Nicaragua
2016La Flor Dominicana Andalusian Bull96Dominican Republic
2017Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Eye of the Shark97Dominican Republic
2018E.P. Carrillo Encore Majestic96Dominican Republic
2019Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua Maestro96Nicaragua
2020E.P. Carrillo Pledge Prequel98Dominican Republic
2021Padrón 1964 Anniversary Series Torpedo97Nicaragua
2022H. Upmann No. 298Cuba
2023Fuente Fuente OpusX Reserva d'Chateau97Dominican Republic
2024My Father The Judge Grand Robusto98Nicaragua
2025Padrón 60th Anniversary Perfecto97Nicaragua

Read down the last column and the balance of the modern cigar world appears. Of the 22 winners from 2004 to 2025, 11 were made in Nicaragua, 6 in the Dominican Republic, 4 in Cuba and 1 in Honduras. Padrón alone has won five times. Cuban cigars compete on equal terms, even though they cannot legally be sold in the United States, where most of the magazine's readers live. Several of these cigars have lessons of their own in Iconic Cigars, among them Opus X, Cohiba Behike, My Father Le Bijou 1922 and Padron 1926 Series.

The Big Smoke and other events

The magazine carried its idea off the page early. The first Big Smoke, an evening at which readers pay to taste cigars from many makers in one room, was held at a hotel in New York in 1993 and sold out. A Las Vegas edition followed in November 1996, opening with a morning of seminars by the magazine's editors and cigar makers that drew fewer than 100 people; today more than 500 attend the seminars and thousands the full weekend, and the show has been cancelled only once, in November 2020, during the pandemic. Since 2021 the Big Smoke has also been held in Hollywood, Florida, together with the publisher's whisky festival. In 1993 the magazine also began an annual charity dinner, A Night to Remember, raising money for prostate cancer research. International Cigar Festivals describes the wider calendar these events belong to.

Criticism

Health researchers have studied the magazine as cigar marketing. A 2001 study found that its articles linked cigars with glamour, wealth and celebrity, and that only about 1 percent of them dealt mainly with the health effects of smoking. A study of the six issues published in 2023 counted 276 advertisements and 133 articles: cigars appeared in 64.5 percent of the advertisements and 49.6 percent of the articles, alcohol was the next most common theme, and no article covered health. Among the cigar advertisements whose origin could be identified, 65 percent were for Nicaraguan cigars and about 25 percent for Dominican ones. The same studies note what the magazine itself says: that it was made for adult smokers of premium cigars and that its blind tastings are its answer to bias. Both views explain its weight. A publication that rates the products of the companies that advertise in it must show that its scores cannot be bought, and the blind tasting is how it does so.

The magazine today

Cigar Aficionado is published six times a year by M. Shanken Communications in New York, which also publishes magazines on wine and whisky. The magazine reports a print circulation of about 250,000; figures for its total audience vary with the source and the date, from about 1.3 million to more than 2.7 million readers across print and digital. David Savona is its executive editor, and a former executive editor, Gordon Mott, was named Habanos Man of the Year in the communications category in 2017. Marvin R. Shanken, its founder, editor and publisher, died on October 29, 2026, aged 83. The magazine he started remains the reference point that makers measure their cigars against and that shops put in their windows.

Log in to save this lesson as read and build your topic progress.

Log in
Lesson 11 of 11 · 39 min readAccessories IndustryA cigar burns away in an hour; the lighter, cutter and humidor that serve it can last a lifetime. A small group of companies makes those tools. Some are luxury houses that began in leather goods, such as S.T. Dupont (Paris, 1872) and Dunhill (London, 1893). Others are specialists: Zippo and Colibri in lighters, Xikar in cutters, Elie Bleu in humidors, Boveda in humidity packs. This lesson covers who they are, who owns them, how they make and price their goods, and the rules that govern lighters.Next lesson