Cigarero

Collectibility & Investment Value

A few limited editions have risen steeply in price on the secondary market, and that has led many people to call cigars an investment. They are not, in any sense that a financial adviser would recognize. A limited edition gains value only when it is genuinely scarce, carries real provenance, comes from a house people trust and can be kept in good condition for years; most releases meet none of those tests at once, and a cigar that is smoked is gone. Treat a limited edition as a cigar to enjoy, and regard any appreciation as a bonus, not a plan.

This lesson looks squarely at why some limited cigars rise in price, why most do not, and what a collector can realistically expect. It is deliberately measured, because the cigar trade, encouraged by buyers, has long used the language of investment to sell rarity. The Cigar Boxes topic covers the packaging and numbering that a buyer reads, and the Types of Limited Editions lesson sets out the scarcity of each kind.

Where limited-edition value comes from

When a limited edition does rise, it is usually because several things come together. The first is true scarcity: a genuinely small run, counted in numbered boxes, whose supply only shrinks as people smoke it. The second is provenance, the particular story that attaches a cigar to an anniversary, an event or a leaf that cannot be replaced. The third is the house behind it, because a maker with a long record of quality and honest numbering commands more trust than a name attached to a one-off. The fourth is age, since a cigar that is known to improve as it rests is worth more kept than smoked now. The fifth is condition, since a scarce cigar stored badly is worth little no matter how few exist.

Each of these alone does nothing. A small run of an unknown blend means little, and a famous house's ordinary cigar, however good, is not scarce. It is the coincidence of all five that has made icons of the handful of releases described in the next lesson.

Why most limiteds do not rise

Most limited editions never become more valuable, and the reasons are worth stating plainly. The market has been flooded with "limited" releases, so many that the word has worn thin; a cigar released as limited but made in a large, unnumbered run is not scarce in the way that matters. Smoking a cigar also destroys it, so the pool of a given release only ever shrinks, and there is no liquid market in which most releases can be re-sold at all; a box may be worth more on paper than anyone is prepared to pay. Storage carries its own cost and risk, as beetles, mould and a dry or over-wet humidor can ruin a box over the years. And the price at which a cigar was bought already includes its rarity, so the buyer is usually paying for the scarcity up front rather than acquiring it for nothing.

Cigars are not an investment

The honest version is short. Cigars produce no income, carry no claim on anything, and their value depends on the continued desire of a small group of collectors and on perfect storage. A few famous Cuban and Dominican releases have sold at auction for many times their release price, and their history is genuinely interesting, but they are the exceptions, and even their price reflects what someone was willing to pay for the object as a collectible, not a return that can be planned on. A collector is best served by buying cigars to smoke and to share, buying what is liked, and keeping a few to age for the pleasure of smoking them later. If one of those few happens to appreciate, that is a windfall.

Keeping a limited edition

For anyone who does set a limited edition aside, the practical rules are simple and widely taught. Keep the cigar at about 21 °C (70 °F) and about 70 percent relative humidity, the figures the trade shortens to the 70/70 rule, in a humidor that holds a steady level; swings in either direction do more harm than a steady, slightly imperfect level. Keep boxes closed and stored flat or as the maker packed them, and be sparing about opening aging boxes, since every opening changes the air inside. The point of all of it is the same one this lesson began with: a limited edition is a cigar, and its real value is the smoking of it.

Log in to save this lesson as read and build your topic progress.

Log in
Lesson 4 of 4 · 9 min readIconic Limited EditionsA handful of limited editions are famous enough that their names are known far beyond the people who smoke them. Cuba's annual Edición Limitada has run every year since 2000, and the Cohiba Behike line, with its three sizes, set the top of the Cuban price list when it arrived in 2010. Outside Cuba, Fuente Fuente OpusX broke open Dominican wrapper in 1995 and the Padrón Family Reserve has marked the family's milestones each year since 2009 with leaf aged a decade. These are not the whole of cigar history, but they are the releases most often pointed to when collectors talk about rarity.Next lesson