A cigar's smoke carries hundreds of compounds, and no two smokers put exactly the same name to them. To make tasting describable rather than a private guess, the trade groups those tastes and smells into families, as a wine taster groups red fruit or a coffee buyer groups chocolate notes. A flavor family is a set of related notes that usually come from the same source and sit close together on the tongue or the nose. This lesson sets out the families tasters reach for most, what usually produces each one and where in a smoke each tends to appear. How to Taste and Describe shows how to find them in a cigar, and Building Vocabulary gives the words to write them down.
The flavor wheel
The families are often drawn as a wheel, with the notes of each family around a spoke, so that a taster can point to where a cigar's character sits. Stores and reviewers use a handful of families in common. Wood covers cedar, oak, pine and well-aged wood; earth covers soil, forest floor, minerals, mushrooms and clay; spice runs from black and white pepper to baking spices such as cinnamon, nutmeg and clove; sweetness covers honey, caramel, molasses and the leaf's own natural sugar; nuts covers almond, hazelnut, walnut, peanut and cashew; coffee and cocoa covers espresso, roasted coffee, milk and dark chocolate; floral covers rose, jasmine and perfumed leaf; grass and hay covers freshly cut green and the lighter, haylike notes of shade-grown leaf; leather and pepper stand on their own, the pepper usually kept apart from the baking spices because it behaves so differently in a smoke.
The families are a map, not a measure. Read altogether, they say nothing about whether a cigar is good or bad, strong or mild: those are body and strength, which the Strength vs. Body topic separates. The families only name what is there to be found. A taster usually names the family that leads, then the notes inside it, then the one or two families that follow. "Cedar and earth with a black-pepper finish" says more in six words than a string of ungrouped notes.
Where the families come from
Most of a cigar's flavor comes from its filler, simply because the filler is most of the tobacco, and the leaf's own chemistry, its fermentation and its age decide which families appear. The wrapper, the first leaf you taste and the one that burns all along the outside, colors every puff with its oils and sweetness, as Wrapper's Influence on Body explains, and a second family, cedar, can come either from the leaf or from the Spanish-cedar box or humidor the cigar has rested in. No family is a sign of quality on its own; each appears when the leaf, the fermentation and the blend are arranged for it.
Wood is the most common family, and of its notes cedar leads, because most cigars rest in Spanish cedar, while oak and pine come from the leaf itself. Sweetness is mostly the leaf's own sugar, released most fully by tobacco that has been fermented long enough for its starches to turn to sugar, which is why dark, long-fermented maduro wrappers taste sweet without any flavoring added; Habanos stresses that the color of its wrappers comes from the leaf and the way it is fermented, entirely naturally. Coffee and cocoa rise in the same way, from the bound-up sugars of a heavier leaf, and appear most in medium-to-full blends. Nuts are tied to particular tobaccos, above all the mild, aromatic Olor Dominicano, and people often describe Dominican cigars as nutty and creamy for that reason.
The families through a smoke
Families are not spread evenly through a cigar. The first third is usually led by the wrapper and the lighter notes, so wood, hay and a little cream appear early, as Flavor Development explains. Once the burn settles in the second third, the middle of the blend opens and nuts, cocoa and coffee come forward. In the final third, when the smoke runs hotter and more concentrated, the heavier notes, earth, leather and black pepper, take over. Spice behaves a little on its own: black pepper is often strongest at the very start, right after lighting, and again at the end, while the gentler baking spices belong to the middle and to cigars that have been aged.
The table gathers the families with their usual notes, where they tend to come from and when they usually show.
| Family | Notes often named | Where it usually comes from | When it usually shows |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wood | Cedar, oak, pine, aged wood | Spanish-cedar storage, and the leaf's own oils | The first third, and lighter blends |
| Earth | Soil, forest floor, minerals, mushroom, clay | The lower, more earthy filler leaves and certain soils | The second and final thirds |
| Spice | Black, white and red pepper; cinnamon, nutmeg, clove | The upper leaves, and fermentation, for the baking spices | Pepper at lighting and at the end; baking spices mid-smoke and in aged cigars |
| Sweetness | Honey, caramel, molasses, natural tobacco sugar | Well-fermented leaf whose starches have turned to sugar | Through the smoke, most in a maduro |
| Nuts | Almond, hazelnut, walnut, cashew | Mild, aromatic leaf such as Olor Dominicano | The second third, as the burn steadies |
| Coffee and cocoa | Espresso, roasted coffee, milk and dark chocolate | Heavier, oilier leaf and fermented sugars | The second and final thirds |
| Floral | Rose, jasmine, tea, perfumed leaf | Certain tobaccos, brought out by a retrohale | Later, and on the nose |
| Grass and hay | Fresh-cut grass, hay, straw | Thin, shade-grown leaf and young tobacco | The first third |
| Leather | Leather, tanned hide | Older, fully fermented leaf | The final third |
| Pepper | Black and white pepper | The upper leaves of the filler | At lighting, then again at the end |
Naming against the ligero myth
One family is easy to misread, and a common error is worth setting straight. Pepper, earth and leather are often said to come from the ligero. They often do, because the deeper, fermented upper leaves carry them, but ligero itself is not a flavor. It names where a leaf grew on the plant, the thick, oily upper leaves that run at the center of the bunch, as Filler Leaf Positions (Primings) and Strength: Nicotine and Ligero explain. What ligero brings is nicotine, which is strength, and fullness, which is body, not a taste of its own. Two cigars with the same share of ligero can taste of quite different families, and a mild cigar can carry plenty of pepper at lighting. A note on the wheel describes a taste; ligero describes a leaf.
Two, three, four families
Few good cigars belong to one family alone. A Partagás Serie D No. 4, a full Cuban robusto, is usually described as earthy and woody with black pepper at the start and a leather, cocoa finish, so three or four families run through a single cigar. The Nicaraguan Padrón 1964 Anniversary Series, a puro whose wrapper, binder and filler all come from Nicaragua, is often described as cocoa and coffee over earth and sweet spice, while the Dominican Fuente Fuente OpusX carries cedar and earth with a long, sweet finish, and the Honduran Camacho Corojo, wrapped in the Eiroa family's Corojo leaf from Jamastrán, is known for a strong, peppery, full flavor. Each shows how families combine, and how country, seed and fermentation set the mix. Building Vocabulary shows how to write that down so another smoker can follow you.
