Cigarero

NewsLegislation

An appeals court rules for the cigar industry again

A federal appeals court refused the FDA's appeal, confirming that the premium cigar rule had been struck down lawfully.

Cigarero

An appeals court rules for the cigar industry again

Two days after the flavor bans were shelved, a federal appeals court refused the FDA's appeal of the 2023 decision that had struck down its premium cigar rule.

The procedural history is short and took most of a decade. The agency asserted authority over cigars in 2016, wrote the rule that put them under the cigarette regime, defended it through years of litigation, lost the substantive argument in August 2023, and then appealed that loss.

By refusing the appeal, the court left the lower ruling in place. The rule that had subjected premium cigars to the cigarette framework no longer stood, and the reasoning behind it had been tested twice.

One route remained, and the agency took it. A final ruling from the same court the following year would close the question, but not before the industry had spent another year arguing it.

Two wins in three days, one legislative and one judicial, marked the high point of a decade of lobbying for the premium trade.

More news

All news →