NewsLegislation
A court keeps the premium cigar definition, but flavors stay regulated
A federal appeals court upheld the premium cigar definition, but flavored cigars remained outside the exemption.
Cigarero

In April 2026 a federal appeals court in Washington issued its final ruling on the definition of a premium cigar, closing a case that had run for most of a decade.
The definition survived. Hand-rolled cigars with a wrapper leaf, no characterizing flavor and sold as a single cigar remain outside the cigarette regime, and the compliance burden that the 2016 rule imposed on them is gone for good.
Flavored cigars did not get the exemption and stayed regulated as before. The line the court drew was the same one the industry had drawn itself: flavor is the dividing mark.
It was the third time the industry had won at that level, after the 2023 vacatur and the 2025 refusal to hear the appeal. The rule it had been fighting since 2016 no longer exists.
The argument then moved to what replaces it. Within months the agency had proposed a new registration scheme for tobacco products, and the trade was reading it for the same risks under a different name.


