Cigarero

NewsLegislation

The FDA moves to ban menthol cigarettes and flavored cigars

The FDA announced plans to ban menthol cigarettes and flavored cigars, putting the premium cigar trade on notice.

Cigarero

The FDA moves to ban menthol cigarettes and flavored cigars

On 29 April 2021 the United States Food and Drug Administration announced that it would pursue a ban on menthol cigarettes and on cigars with characterizing flavors. It was the most consequential statement the agency had made about tobacco since it claimed authority over cigars five years earlier.

That authority came from the deeming rule of 2016, which brought cigars, pipe tobacco and vaping products under the same law as cigarettes. From August 2016 any tobacco product that was not on the market on 15 February 2007 needed the agency's authorisation before it could be sold. For a handmade cigar that has been made in one size for a century, that meant proving it was substantially equivalent to something that in most cases no longer existed.

Compliance was priced out of reach. A single application could cost more than a small factory earns in a year, and there are thousands of sizes across the industry. The trade argued from the start that a hand-rolled cigar bought in a specialist shop has little in common with a pack of cigarettes, and that a regime designed for one should not be applied to the other.

The 2021 announcement did not touch unflavored premium cigars directly. What it did was put the principle on the table: that the agency was willing to ban whole categories of tobacco product, and that the arguments about how a product is actually used carried little weight.

Nothing happened immediately. A proposed rule, a comment period, a review and then signature were all still ahead, and in the end none of it would arrive.

More news

All news →