Cigarero

NewsLegislation

A federal judge strikes down the FDA's premium cigar rule

A federal judge threw out the rule that treated premium cigars like cigarettes, a landmark win for the industry.

Cigarero

A federal judge strikes down the FDA's premium cigar rule

On 10 August 2023 a federal judge in Washington struck down the FDA's rule subjecting premium cigars to the same regime as cigarettes. It was the most significant legal result the industry had won since the agency claimed authority over cigars in 2016.

The rule at issue was the deeming regulation: it made cigars tobacco products under the law, and it required any product not on the market by February 2007 to seek authorisation. For handmade cigars that meant a substantial equivalence application for thousands of sizes, at a cost no small factory could bear.

The court held that the agency had not adequately considered the evidence about premium cigars, including how they are used and by whom, before deciding to regulate them as it regulated cigarettes. A rule built without that consideration could not stand.

The practical effect was immediate for the industry and narrow in scope. It removed the compliance burden from premium cigars; it did not deregulate tobacco, and it left flavored cigars and mass-market products where they were.

The agency appealed, so the win was provisional. It held, and it became the foundation for everything that came after.

More news

All news →