Cigarero

NewsLegislation

The Supreme Court lets California's flavor ban stand

The US Supreme Court declined to block California's ban on flavored tobacco, clearing the way for it to take effect.

Cigarero

The Supreme Court lets California's flavor ban stand

In December 2022 the Supreme Court refused to block California's ban on flavored tobacco products, allowing a law approved by voters that November to take effect.

The measure had been passed by the state legislature and then put to a referendum, where it won comfortably. It banned the sale of flavored tobacco products, including menthol cigarettes and flavored cigars, and it exempted premium cigars, pipe tobacco and loose leaf.

The exemption is the part that mattered to this trade, and it was written narrowly. A premium cigar was defined by how it is made and sold: hand-rolled, wrapper leaf, no characterizing flavor, sold as a single cigar. A flavored cigar, however it is made, was not covered by it.

Retailers had to clear shelves of products that had been legal the week before, and enforcement fell to a state that had just been given the green light. California is the largest state market in the country, and what it does tends to be copied.

Other states and cities followed with restrictions of their own, and the exemptions varied. A manufacturer selling nationally soon had a patchwork of rules to work with rather than one.

More news

All news →